Whether Issue Estoppel Founded on Privity of Estate Applies to Prior Purchaser

In the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Holden at Abuja

On Friday, the 21st day of February, 2025

Before Their Lordships

Adamu Jauro

Moore Aseimo Abraham Adumein

Habeeb Adewale Olumuyiwa Abiru

Jamilu Yammama Tukur

Abubakar Sadiq Umar

Justices, Supreme Court

SC/190/2008

Between

MS MARY ESSIEN APPELLANT                                                                 

       And

1.  SUSAN-OHIO INVESTMENTS LIMITED RESPONDENTS

2. HUBERT O. OGAR

3. NIGERIAN UNION OF TEACHERS 

    (CROSS RIVER STATE WING)

(Lead Judgement delivered by Honourable Habeeb Adewale Olumuyiwa Abiru, JSC)

Facts

The Appellant’s mother – Dr (Mrs) Margaret Essien commenced an action at the High Court of Cross River State against her husband – Obong Joseph Effiong Essien sometime in April 2002, seeking inter alia, a declaration that the building at No. 12 MCC Road, Calabar, covered by a Certificate of Occupancy registered as No. 35 at Page 35 in Volume 199 of the Land Registry Office in Calabar is the joint property of herself and Obong Joseph Effiong Essien. She also sought an order of injunction, restraining him from dealing with the property adversely against her interest. She claimed that the property was jointly built by her and Obong Essien. 

In his defence, Obong Essien claimed that he is the sole owner of the house, and he solely funded the acquisition of the land and the construction of the property without any contribution from Dr (Mrs) Essien. He also claimed that he obtained a Certificate of Occupancy on the property in his name as the sole owner, and subsequently, sold the property to the 1st and 2nd Respondent in that capacity. In the course of the proceedings, the 1st and 2nd Respondent were joined as 2nd and 3rd Defendant. The 1st and 2nd Respondent filed their Statement of Defence and counter-claimed inter-alia, for a declaration that the assignment of the property to them was valid in law.

The 3rd Respondent was subsequently joined as the 4th Defendant, and in its Statement of Defence, it averred that the subject property had been sold to it by the 1st and 2nd Respondent. Thereafter, the matter proceeded to trial. During the pendency of the matter, Obong Essien commenced divorce proceedings against Dr (Mrs) Essien before another High Court in Calabar in Suit No. HC/8D/2002. Judgement was delivered in Suit No. HC/8D/2002, when the instant suit was at the point of adoption of final addresses. In the judgement, it was held that the property in dispute was the joint property of Obong Essien and Dr (Mrs) Essien. Thereafter, Counsel to Dr (Mrs) Essien filed an application, seeking to tender the judgement as additional evidence. 

The trial court took the application, and the adoption of final address on the substantive suit together. The trial court prefaced its judgement with a ruling on the admissibility of the judgement in Suit No. HC/8D/2002, and held that the judgement was not pleaded and as such was inadmissible, but it would take judicial notice of the same being the judgement of a court of competent jurisdiction. In its judgement on the substantive suit, the trial court found that Dr (Mrs) Essien failed to prove her claim of joint ownership of the property, and that Obong Essien being the sole owner of the property had the power to sell the same without her consent. The Court also granted the counter-claim of the 1st and 2nd Respondent, save their prayer for an order compelling Dr (Mrs) Essien to pay mesne profits to them. 

Aggrieved, Dr (Mrs) Essien appealed to the Court of Appeal. However, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal for being unmeritorious. Dr (Mrs) Essien thus, filed a further appeal at the Supreme Court. Dr (Mrs) Essien and Obong Essien died after the appeal was filed, and while Dr (Mrs) Essien was substituted with the present Appellant, the name of Obong Essien was struck out as a party in the appeal. 

Issue for Determination

The Apex Court subsumed the issues formulated by the parties into the following sole issue:

Whether, on the state of the cases made out by the parties in their respective pleadings and evidence led thereon before the trial court, the lower Court was correct in affirming the findings and the conclusions reached by the trial court in dismissing the claims of the Appellant and granting the counter-claims of the Respondents.

Arguments

Counsel for the Appellant contended that the judgement in Suit No. HC/8D/2002 which declared the property in dispute as the joint property of Dr (Mrs) Essien and Obong Essien, constituted issue estoppel on the pending issue before the trial court of whether the property was the joint property of the two. Counsel argued that further deliberations by the trial court on the issue after the judgment in Suit No. HC/8D/2002 had been brought to its attention, was tantamount to the trial court indulging in abuse of court process and the Court of Appeal was wrong to have endorsed the trial court’s finding. 

Counsel argued further that the lower court was also in error when it upheld the trial court’s decision, discountenancing the caveat filed by Dr (Mrs) Essien against the sale of the property at the Lands Registry, Calabar. Counsel submitted that having admitted the caveat in evidence despite the objection of Counsel for the Respondents, the trial court was wrong to have subsequently discountenanced it on the ground that it was inauthentic. 

In response, Counsel for the 1st Respondent argued that the 1st Respondent had purchased the property in dispute from Obong Essien before the divorce proceedings in Suit No. HC/8D/2002 was commenced, and the law as pronounced in TALABI v ADESEYE (1973) 1 NMLR 8 is that the judgement obtained in the divorce proceedings cannot constitute issue estoppel against the 1st Respondent. Counsel submitted that since the 1st Respondent had acquired proprietary interest in the property upon purchase, it must be made a party in any suit touching on title to the property commenced thereafter, to enable it defend its proprietary interest and to be bound by the outcome of the action.

Counsel for the 2nd Respondent submitted that the production of the judgement in Suit No HC/8D/2002 before the trial court by Counsel for the Appellant was tantamount to leading evidence outside the pleadings, and the trial court was correct in treating the same as irrelevant. Counsel argued that the evidence led by Obong Essien on his sole ownership of the property in dispute outweighed the case made out by Dr (Mrs) Essien on joint ownership of the property, and this gave credence to the claims of the 1st and 2nd Respondent who derived title to the property from Obong Essien. 

Respective Counsel for all Respondents submitted that the lower courts were correct in their concurrent findings against the Appellant.

Court’s Judgement and Rationale

The Apex Court held that a plea of estoppel, be it issue estoppel or per rem judicatam, must be mutually enforceable; thus, where privity of estate is set up as the foundation for its application, the title relied on to establish such privity must have arisen after the judgement on which the estoppel is based, or at least, after the commencement of the proceedings in the course of which judgement was given. The Court referred to the decision in OMIYALE v MACAULAY (2009) 7 NWLR (PT. 1141) 597. The Supreme Court held that in other words, a prior purchaser of land cannot be estopped as being privy in estate, by a judgement obtained in an action commenced against the vendor after the purchase. The Court placed further reliance on its decisions in TALABI v ADESEYE (1972) 8-9 SC 55 at 84 and AJEIGBE v ODEDINA (1988) 1 NWLR (PT. 72) 584.

The Court also referred to its decision in AKANDE v ALAGA (1988) 4 NWLR (PT. 86) in which it held that: “where a third party acquires an interest in property before the filing of a suit leading to the judgement pleaded as res judicata to defeat a subsequent action instituted by the third party, and the third party was not proved to be standing by at the time of the action, his claim cannot be defeated by the plea of res judicata. This is because the action leading to the judgement was instituted after he had acquired interest in the property, and he was not joined in the suit”.

The Apex Court held that it was not in contest that the Respondents acquired their respective titles to the property in dispute long before the divorce proceedings in Suit No. HC/8D/2002 was commenced, and before the issue of the joint ownership of the property was brought into the proceedings by Dr (Mrs) Margaret Essien in her cross- petition and much earlier than the date when judgement was entered in the action, and the Respondents were not made parties to the proceedings. The Court found that the divorce proceedings could not thus, operate to create an estoppel of whatever nature in the present proceedings; hence, the judgement was irrelevant to the present proceedings and it got the appropriate treatment it deserved from the two lower courts.

On the complaint of the Appellant’s Counsel on the refusal of the two lower courts to accord any probative value to the caveat alleged to have been filed by Dr (Mrs) Essien despite the trial court having admitted it as Exhibit 7, the Apex Court held that the fact that a piece of evidence is admitted does not translate to it being accorded weight or probative value by a trial court. The Court held that if a piece of documentary evidence is relevant, the court admits it once all other aspects of our adjectival laws are in favour of such admission; however the weight or probative value to be ascribed to it is based on factors such as relevance, credibility, probability and conclusiveness on the issues in respect of which it was put in evidence.  

The Supreme Court held that in the present case, the caveat was admitted in evidence in the course of trial, however, in the course of its deliberations in the judgement, the trial court, in light of other facts and other pieces of evidence, found that the document was not credible and not conclusive enough to prove the fact it was put forward to establish, and consequently accorded it no weight or probative value. The Court found that the arguments canvassed by the Appellant on this point are the same arguments she canvassed before the Court of Appeal which the lower court considered and rejected, and the Appellant had not presented the Apex Court with any errors committed by the lower court in rejecting the arguments, to warrant the Apex Court’s interference.

The Supreme Court held further that an appellate court has no business dabbling into conclusions reached by a lower court in respect of which an appellant has not placed any contestation before it. The Apex Court found the Appellant having not appealed against the concurrent findings of the two lower courts that Dr (Mrs) Essien did not lead any credible and cogent evidence of her direct financial contribution to either the acquisition of the land or to the construction of the property in dispute, the Apex Court had no reason to interfere with the findings.

Appeal Dismissed.

Representation

O. J. Aboje with Emmanuel Ekong for the Appellant.

Dafe Diegbe for the 1st Respondent.

Chris Ohene with Ishaq Muhammed for the 2nd Respondent.

Efa O. Oka for the 3rd Respondent. 

Reported by Optimum Publishers Limited, Publishers of the Nigerian Monthly Law Reports (NMLR)(An affiliate of Babalakin & Co.)

The post Whether Issue Estoppel Founded on Privity of Estate Applies to Prior Purchaser appeared first on THISDAYLIVE.

​  

  • Related Posts

    Tinubu: No Nigerian is Second-class Citizen, Reiterates Every Region Being Carried Along in His Government

    Tinubu: No Nigerian is Second-class Citizen, Reiterates Every Region Being Carried Along in His Government

    •Says he’s on oath to serve all Nigerians, not a particular section

    Deji Elumoye in Abuja

    President Bola Tinubu, yesterday, declared that in his over two-year-old administration, no Nigerian was being regarded as second-class citizen, while no region was left behind in developmental efforts.
    Tinubu, in a verified post on his handle, @officialABAT, stressed that he was on oath to serve all Nigerians and not a particular section of the country.
    He listed several projects, including bridges, roads, rail, health centres, as well as power, agriculture, and oil and gas schemes spread across the six geo-political zones being executed by his government.
    Tinubu, in the post, stated, “Dear Nigerians, I took an oath to serve all Nigerians, not a section. That oath guides every bridge, road, rail, power, and health project we deliver.
    “From the Lagos–Calabar Highway in the South to the Sokoto–Badagry Superhighway in the North; from Port Harcourt–Maiduguri rail in the East to Abuja–Kaduna–Kano expressway in the Centre, and the Trans-Saharan highway connecting African countries, these are not local trophies. They are our national assets.
    “Health centres are being rehabilitated nationwide, light rail projects in Kano, Kaduna, Lagos & Ogun have been given the green light, 250,000 jobs are being created, power is returning to Kaduna through the revived 255MW power plant, bridges in Onitsha & Bonny reconnect our people, oil exploration is expanding in Bauchi & Gombe, and the AKK pipeline has crossed the Niger.
    “Every farmer who needs a road, every trader who needs power, every child who needs a school, every patient who needs care… this is who we are building for.
    “This is the equity of Renewed Hope. No Nigerian is second-class; no region is left behind. Together we will rise as one nation, one people, and one destiny. Bet on Nigeria.”

    The post Tinubu: No Nigerian is Second-class Citizen, Reiterates Every Region Being Carried Along in His Government appeared first on THISDAYLIVE.

    ​  

    •Says he’s on oath to serve all Nigerians, not a particular section Deji Elumoye in Abuja President Bola Tinubu, yesterday, declared that in his over two-year-old administration, no Nigerian was
    The post Tinubu: No Nigerian is Second-class Citizen, Reiterates Every Region Being Carried Along in His Government appeared first on THISDAYLIVE.

    Tinubu Assures Colombia of Prompt Implementation of All Bilateral Agreements

    Tinubu Assures Colombia of Prompt Implementation of All Bilateral Agreements

    •As Nigeria, Colombia sign historic MoU to enhance political, economic ties
    •Shettima asks both nations to transform potential into tangible economic gains beyond tariff barriers
    •Nigeria remains strategic market for Colombia, says Márquez

    Deji Elumoye in Abuja

    President Bola Tinubu has reaffirmed Nigeria’s commitment to strengthening international partnerships and aligning its foreign relations with evolving global trends in trade, politics, and culture.
    Tinubu spoke on Monday while receiving in audience Vice President of the Republic of Colombia, Francia Márquez, at State House, Abuja.
    He stated that global economic volatility and shifting international policies will necessitate new partners for shared prosperity.
    Tinubu assured the delegation of senior government, business, and diplomatic officials from the South American country that Nigeria will replicate the agreements signed with Brazil on aviation and consular issues with Colombia.
    He stated that the conclusions of all the bilateral meetings and the agreements signed, under the supervision of Vice President Kashim Shettima, will receive speedy attention.
    The president stated, “I believe the vice president and his team have done the job. Our business opportunities with Colombia have already been enhanced. I support every aspect that you have agreed on.
    “Particularly for Colombia, the agreement we entered with Brazil can easily be replicated in aviation, and our diplomatic relations can be enhanced. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs will accelerate that.”
    Tinubu urged the business leaders to explore opportunities in Nigeria’s oil and gas sector and agriculture.
    He said Nigeria’s youthful and growing population presented a good market and a skilled workforce to boost investment.
    Shettima said the visit by the Colombian vice president would rekindle ancestral connections disrupted by slavery and colonialism, positioning both nations for a prosperous partnership.
    He highlighted the political and cultural similarities that would foster healthy economic collaboration.
    Similarly, the vice president of Colombia highlighted several areas for the strengthening of bilateral relations, including aviation, visas, political consultations, cultural exchanges, and trade.
    Márquez stated, “As the first black Vice President of Colombia, I am extremely delighted to lead this visit to the land of our ancestors. Our ancestors were taken away from Africa centuries ago.”
    She said her visit will kick-start a long-lasting relationship built on substantial cultural similarity and heritage.
    Márquez assured that relations with Nigeria would benefit both countries, particularly in areas such as social justice, gender equality, and inclusivity.
    “We have had a meeting with the business leaders in aviation on the need to start direct flights to Colombia,” she added.
    Marquez said Nigeria’s leadership role in Africa and African Union’s role in restoration and reparation will enhance relations with Latin America and the Caribbean.
    Earlier on Monday, Nigeria and Colombia signed a historic Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on political consultations, opening a new and significant chapter in relations between both countries.
    The MoU signed during the Nigeria-Colombia Bilateral Meeting and Business Forum at State House, Abuja, was endorsed by Nigeria’s Minister of Foreign Affairs, Ambassador Yusuf Tuggar, and Deputy Minister, Multilateral Affairs, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Colombia, Mauricio Jaramillo Jassir.
    Jassir explained that on the bilateral front, the MoU related to “very frequent political dialogue” with Nigeria and visa approvals for its diplomats, thereby making it easier for its diplomats to visit Nigeria.
    Speaking at the plenary session of the Nigeria-Colombia Business Forum, Shettima implored both Nigeria and Colombia to take advantage of their abundant potential and turn them into palpable and substantial economic gains. He said this should be driven by the private sectors of the two nations, as they explored new opportunities, deepened partnerships, and addressed common challenges.
    According to him, “We cannot achieve that unless we compare our differences and similarities, as well as our resources and potential. This is a practical way to propel trade and investment, improve agriculture, foster culture, and exchange ideas that will mutually benefit our countries.
    “The private sectors of our two nations are therefore urged to take advantage of the abundant potential of our countries and transform them into tangible economic gains.”
    Shettima also stated that while the scepticism about the global economy and its unpredictable politics were redefining trade patterns, Nigeria had since deemed it necessary to diversify and expand its exports beyond crude oil, with agriculture, minerals, and manufactured products as some of the new areas of concentration.
    He said, “The tariffs that confront our exports in other parts of the world are a reminder of the danger of dependence on a narrow base.
    “For Nigeria, this is a call to diversify our exports beyond crude oil, expanding into agriculture, minerals, and manufactured products. I believe that Colombia too is bound by the determination to expand its economy beyond the bounds of tariff barriers.”
    Responding to the global constraints, the vice president explained that Nigeria was working towards elevating its agriculture from subsistence to mega-business, as well as transforming smallholders into global conglomerates.
    According to him, “As a country, we are investing in innovative technologies for livestock breeding, developing machinery, producing chemical-based products, such as fertilisers, herbicides, and pesticides, and creating a strong supply chain. This is also an area where partnerships with Colombia will be vital.
    “We must prioritise sectors that are natural pillars of our economies. In agriculture, we share comparative strengths in cocoa, coffee, and tropical fruits. In energy, Nigeria remains a leader in oil and gas, while Colombia has potential in coal and renewable energy.
    “In manufacturing, from textiles to machinery, both nations can collaborate to build capacity, exchange knowledge, and attract the kind of investments that secure jobs and prosperity for our peoples.”
    To take advantage of the opportunities that abound in their domains, Shettima identified three things both Nigeria and Colombia must do, including monitoring “global trade policies to adapt swiftly”.
    He said both nations must diversify exports to reduce dependence on single products, and “create a business environment attractive enough for foreign investors,” adding that by pursuing these, both nations “can turn shifting tides into shared prosperity”.
    On cultural ties between both nations, the vice president said, “Our practical roadmap to the future is to acknowledge that culture is a bridge for innovation, economic development, and mutual prosperity.
    “Nigeria’s creative sector remains an engine for unleashing the potential of our teeming youth population. Reinforcing our connections in culture, education, science, and technology is fundamental for building a resilient and globally competitive creative economy.
    “It is, therefore, time to collaborate in capacity building, skill development, cultural exchange, digital innovation, and intellectual property protection. We must extend our acquaintance to each other’s literature, languages, music, films, arts, and festivals.”
    Márquez said her team was in Nigeria to reaffirm bilateral relations, stating that the country remains a strategic market for Colombia.
    She stated that Colombia was currently exporting to Nigeria, particularly in the field of leather, adding that she seeks to explore new paths with Nigeria in renewable energy.
    Marquez added, “We can make progress in higher education” by connecting Colombian and Nigerian youths.
    According to her, the business meeting in Nigeria will allow Nigeria to explore cooperation opportunities and work together in the fields of technology and services for both countries.
    She thanked the Nigerian government for the hospitality, assuring, “We will work together for social development, social justice, peace, and security for our people.”
    Earlier, Tuggar said Colombia’s history was tied to Nigeria, particularly during the slave trade, when Nigerians found their way to Colombia.
    He said the development was an opportunity to strengthen historical and economic ties between both countries and bolster trade, adding that there “is room for improvement” in areas, such as agriculture, hydrocarbons, and pharmaceuticals.
    Jassir said it was important for Colombia to diversify its relationship with the world, especially with Nigeria.
    For the Colombian side, he stressed the importance of exploring its relations with Nigeria, maintaining that Nigeria remains the best gateway to reinforce bilateral cooperation with Africa. He expressed optimism that the Nigerian side will explore Colombia’s strategic position in South America.
    On the bilateral front, Jassir said two MoUs were of interest to Colombia: to have “very frequent political dialogue” with Nigeria and visa approvals for its diplomats so it will be easier for its diplomats to visit Nigeria.
    Presenting investment opportunities in Nigeria, Deputy Director of the Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission (NIPC), Mr. Emmanuel Longza, said Nigeria was a strategic location, with a population of 250 million and rich natural resources, while investors could enjoy tax duty waivers, among other incentives.
    Longza listed Nigeria’s untapped treasures to include arable lands, solid minerals, crude oil, the creative and art industry, manufacturing, technology, and renewable energy.
    In terms of agriculture, Longza said Nigeria had 34 million hectares of arable land, with only 46 per cent currently cultivated, implying there is a huge opportunity for agricultural production across the country.
    He added that there were industrial parks across Nigeria designed to boost export-oriented industries while attracting businesses.
    On why Colombia mattered to Nigeria, Longza said both countries could collaborate on agricultural opportunities and energy transition, among others.
    Delivering the plenary address on Nigeria’s Trade and Investment Landscape (Impact, Achievements, and Opportunities), Nigeria’s Minister of Industry, Trade and Investment, Dr. Jumoke Oduwole, said Tinubu had taken bold structural steps to correct long-standing macroeconomic distortions through the removal of the petroleum subsidy, exchange rate unification, and fiscal tightening to restore credibility.
    Oduwole added that Nigeria had emerged as the continent’s fintech powerhouse, with top unicorns domiciled in the country.
    “As a result, today we are proud to serve as co-champions of digital trade under the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA),” the minister stated.

    The post Tinubu Assures Colombia of Prompt Implementation of All Bilateral Agreements appeared first on THISDAYLIVE.

    ​  

    •As Nigeria, Colombia sign historic MoU to enhance political, economic ties•Shettima asks both nations to transform potential into tangible economic gains beyond tariff barriers•Nigeria remains strategic market for Colombia, says
    The post Tinubu Assures Colombia of Prompt Implementation of All Bilateral Agreements appeared first on THISDAYLIVE.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Business & Economy

    CBN’s $2 billion FX Forwards Audit: What really happened, why it matters and who books the losses? 

    Exchange rate: Forex traders say Chinese traders now collecting naira instead of dollars  

    MDGIF: Powering Nigeria’s Renewed Gas Infrastructure Drive

    Chevron Shines at Gbaramatu Voice International Anniversary awards

    NIHOTOUR DG Commends NANTA for Effective Self-regulation

    Sub-regional Insurers to Deliberate on Climate Change at WAICA

    Customs Commission Advanced Cargo Screening X-ray Machine at SAHCOL

    Aradel Renews Contractual Commitment to Supply Gas to NLNG 

    Report: Residential, Commercial, Infrastructure Projects Diminishing Agricultural Land

    ARADEL trades N5.3 billion as All-Share Index closes in red on September 1 

    Nigeria’s private sector growth hits 19-month high as demand surges and inflation eases 

    SEC Nigeria launches new website to boost transparency and investor safety 

    Africa imports close to $50 billion worth of food annually- official

    Africa imports close to $50 billion worth of food annually- official

    Payment App, Vban launches to help Africa’s global workforce get paid easier, faster, and without borders

    Titan Trust Bank ceases operations in Nigeria as Union Bank finalizes takeover 

    DMO opens September 2025 FGN savings bonds, rates peak at 16.541% 

    Heirs’ Technologies industry report call for bold investments to unlock Africa’s $700 billion digital economy by 2030 

    Academy Press soars 218% YtD in 2025: What investors should know 

    Verraki Academy: Forging Nigeria’s next generation of enterprise-ready technologists

    Chinese investors eye $720million agriculture, renewable energy projects in Katsina State 

    SO&U, Udeme Ufot Honoured for Advertising Legacy at Brand Handlers Awards

    Petralon: Community Partnership as Recipe for Business Success

    JustMarkets wins the “Best Global Broker 2025” Award at MEI 2025 

    Naira stable in black market as U.S. Dollar weakens globally 

    How to build your wealth with Mshel Homes  

    Nigeria’s gas future: CNG retail may hit N520/SCM to ensure commercial viability 

    How Nigeria can strengthen business competitiveness and attract private investment

    CAP, Fidson, UBA top stock pick this week

    CAP, Fidson, UBA top stock pick this week

    7 things you must know about REDMI 15C 

    Top 10 best-performing Nigerian stocks in August 2025 

    Aradel Holdings Plc celebrates 20 years of continuous production 

    Union Bank of Nigeria completes merger with Titan Trust Bank

    Amidst Demand, Consumer Goods Index Emerges Best Performing Indicator on NGX

    Sanwo-Olu: Technology Adoption, PPP Will Enhance Govt Service Delivery

    Polution: NIMASA Charges Ships Operating in Nigeria on MARPOL Compliance

    Customs Commission Advanced Cargo Screening X-ray Machine at SAHCOL