ON JUSTICE LIMAN, MAHMOOD YAKUBU AND THE NEXT INEC CHAIRMAN

 Any fit and proper person has right to aspire to be INEC chairman, argues SEUN AWOGBENLE

In the last few days, there has been a sudden frenzy around who becomes the next chairman of Nigeria’s electoral body, INEC. This hysteria, which may be well intended in some quarters, has become another weapon of politics for those whose stock in trade is to exploit every national debate for political mileage.

I typically do not worry when I see people try to outmanoeuvre each other in politics; that is the nature of the game. But there is an emerging pattern that has become even more disturbing. That pattern first emerged with the economic reforms of the current government, where people who knocked the reforms were the same people who had either pledged the same commitment in the past or could not say anything tangible that they would do differently. The same pattern emerged during the tax reform bill, where people made it a ‘we vs them’ duel, giving it an ethnic dimension. We are now, once again, seeing the same pattern emerge with the appointment of the next INEC chairman. At the heart of this dangerous pattern is the weaponisation of fake news as an art form to spread fear, cause panic and mislead the public.

In principle, I believe that every Nigerian should be interested in who becomes the next chairman of INEC; moreover, as someone who has dedicated a major part of my time to advocating for electoral reforms, I am absolutely certain that this is evidently a settled matter. But raising the political temperature on such a critical issue does not help anyone. This is the sort of conversation that I believe should be beyond the remit of politics and should instead evoke a sense of patriotism and commitment to the truth.

In the last week, at least two patterns have supported this observation. The first one is from media scholar Prof. Farooq Kperoogi, who first spotlighted Justice Mohammed Abdullahi Liman, a retired judge, as a potential replacement for Prof. Mahmood Yakubu. In his notes from Atlanta, Kperoogi, who admitted he did not know enough about Liman to make a categorical comment, went on to describe him as a loadstone for controversies and attempted to support it with reports that were either inaccurate or deliberately concocted. I will return to some of these wild claims shortly.

The second one is a report from Sahara Reporters, titled ‘Tinubu Directs INEC Chairman Yakubu to Immediately Proceed on Leave For “Betraying APC”, Set to Nominate Successor’. In the said report published on September 24, the author made a poor attempt at fiction by claiming, of its own imagination, that Prof. Yakubu has been asked to go on compulsory leave and that therefore this may be an attempt to force out the INEC chairman, whose end of tenure is just about a month away. I will also return to this shortly. But it is worth noting that these two publications were made within days of each other. Striking.

But what are the main issues here? Sections 154(1) and 153(1) establish the power of the President to appoint the Chairman of INEC and the heads of other similar agencies. There has never been a time in the history of Nigeria where whoever was president that attempted to exercise these powers did not face a pushback. For the simple reason that the President has the constitutional right to appoint anyone at his own discretion, and because in some cases the appointed INEC Chairman could potentially preside over an election where the same president is also a candidate.

Some have argued that this power may limit the ability of whoever is the chairman of INEC to function with autonomy and independence. But this debate is not new; it has been on since 2007, when the Justice Uwais-led committee recommended that the power to appoint the INEC chairman be transferred from the president to the National Judicial Council (NJC). However, that recommendation, till today, is yet to undergo any legislative process. Therefore, anyone who is interested in this amendment should be looking to engage the NationalAssembly.

It is with the same token that I find it uncharitable that anyone would suggest that the government may be trying to force out the outgoing chairman. Prof. Mahmood Yakubu was first announced as INEC Chairman on October 21, 2015, before he was confirmed on October 29, 2015. He completed his first term in November 2020 and was renominated and confirmed for a second term in December 2020.

The constitution allows a two-term limit of a maximum of 10 years for anyone serving as INEC Chairman. In November, Prof. Yakubu would have served out his tenure and would effectively be statute-barred from reappointment. If this is anything to go by, let’s assume, but not concede, that the INEC chairman was asked to proceed on leave; this, in my opinion, would be standard civil service procedure. But attempting to frame it in the manner that the author in the Sahara Reporters report has done is oversimplifying an issue that requires a lot more seriousness. For a moment, we can put jokes aside.

For all his faults, Prof. Yakubu, in the last ten years as INEC Chairman, worked together with civil society organisations to deliver Nigeria’s most consequential Electoral Reform Act in 2022. The landmark reforms in the electoral act opened a new chapter in our election management. Part of the gain is how we have managed to deepen our electoral process with the functionality of technology. From the IREV to BVAS, these are all examples of the modest gains we have recorded. As someone who held leadership positions, I am not one to dismiss any effort. For this, I say fare thee well, Prof. Yakubu.

It is not often that I find myself disappointed in Prof. Farouq Kperoogi. But in this particular instance, I found his judgement questionable. In the same article on INEC and Justice Liman, Prof. Kperoogi made several claims; one of them was specifically about a past judgement, where he claimed that Justice Liman stirred outrage when, in a corruption trial, “the principal defendant walked away with fines while his co-defendant got 20 years”.

The matter in this instance was the one involving a certain Michael Igbinedion and Patrick Eboigbodin of PML Nigeria Limited. The judge (Justice Liman) convicted Eboigbodin for money laundering on counts 50-59, while Igbinedion was convicted on counts 79-81. Igbinedion was sentenced to an option of N1 million fine on each of the three counts and, in default, two years imprisonment. While Eboigbodin was sentenced to two years in prison without an option of a fine.

I do not think that Prof. Kperoogi was expecting two people who were convicted on different counts to get the same judgement. The question, therefore, is where Prof. Kperoogi found the 20 years he amplified in his opinion. Was this an omission or deliberate misinformation? I would think that a scholar of his stature would know better than to mislead the public for whatever reason.

I have never met the judge from Nasarawa, but I would want to believe that if he were truly in the mind of the president for this position, one of the reasons he may be under consideration is because he is from North Central, which has in fact never recorded a chairman of INEC from the region. Moreover, as it stands today, there is no serious contender for the presidency in 2027 from North Central. Amidst all the desperate attempts to paint a picture of a bad judge, Justice Liman retired without blemish.

Everyone should be interested in who becomes the INEC Chairman, because the person carries with them the expectation of every Nigerian, who continues to demand accountability in our election management. But I also believe that those demands should be done with a commitment to the truth. That is the least we expect of those who insist on being seen as the voice of conscience.

 Awogbenle, a Development and Public Policy Professional, writes from United Kingdom. He can be reached via seunawogbenle@gmail.com.

​  

  • Related Posts

    Breaking: South East to Get New State as N’Assembly Committee Approves Landmark Constitutional Amendments

    Breaking: South East to Get New State as N’Assembly Committee Approves Landmark Constitutional Amendments

    *Independent candidacy, extra legislative seats for women also endorsed

    Sunday Aborisade in Abuja

    In a historic decision that could redefine Nigeria’s political architecture and deepen democratic inclusivity, the Joint Committee of the National Assembly on Constitution Review has approved the creation of an additional state for the South East geopolitical zone.

    The committee also agreed to revisit the over 278 pending requests for new local government areas and 55 proposals for new states, noting that additional reviews would be handled by a newly formed subcommittee

    In addition, the committee endorsed independent candidacy for future elections and an extra elective seat for women in every state of the federation.

    The far-reaching resolutions were adopted at the committee’s closed-door retreat held at the Lagos Marriott Hotel, Ikeja, on Saturday.

    The meeting, which began around 4:00 p.m., was jointly presided over by the Deputy President of the Senate, Senator Jibrin Barau, and the Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives, Hon. Benjamin Okezie Kalu, who also chairs the House Ad Hoc Committee on Constitution Review.

    The joint committee, comprising one senator and one member of the House of Representatives from each of the 36 states, deliberated on key constitutional proposals and reached consensus on three transformative reforms.

    They are, the creation of an additional state for the South East, the institutionalisation of independent candidacy, and the establishment of gender-based legislative seats.

    For decades, leaders and stakeholders from the South East have clamoured for a sixth state to ensure parity with other regions of the federation.

    The zone currently has only five states: Abia, Anambra, Ebonyi, Enugu, and Imo. While most others have six and the North West has seven.

    The committee’s unanimous decision, according to sources at the retreat, followed spirited deliberations anchored on equity, justice, and fairness.

    A motion for the new state’s creation was moved by Senator Abdul Ningi (Bauchi Central) and seconded by Hon. Ibrahim Isiaka (Ogun State).

    After robust debate, the proposal received unanimous backing from members of both chambers.

    The resolution, once ratified by the National Assembly and endorsed by at least 24 state Houses of Assembly, as required by the 1999 Constitution, would finally bring the South East to parity with other regions.

    Reacting to the decision, Senator Ali Ndume (APC, Borno South) described the move as “a long-overdue act of fairness and justice.”

    According to him, “No region should be structurally disadvantaged. Giving the South East an additional state restores balance and reinforces national unity.”

    Deputy Speaker Benjamin Kalu, who has been a consistent advocate of the initiative, lauded the decision as “a significant milestone for equity and inclusion in Nigeria’s federal structure.”

    Equally momentous was the committee’s approval of independent candidacy—a reform that will, for the first time, allow qualified Nigerians to contest elections without the sponsorship of political parties.

    The proposal seeks to dismantle the dominance of party oligarchies and expand access to the democratic space, giving room for credible, non-partisan individuals to vie for public office on merit.

    According to insiders, the committee’s debate on the issue was “spirited but progressive,” with lawmakers across party lines agreeing that allowing independents would strengthen accountability and public trust in the electoral process.

    The reform, once passed, would require adjustments to the Electoral Act and the 1999 Constitution to define eligibility, nomination procedures, and campaign financing frameworks for independent candidates.

    In another groundbreaking resolution, the committee approved one additional legislative seat for women in both chambers of the National Assembly for each state of the federation.

    If ratified, this amendment will create 37 new seats in the House of Representatives and 36 new seats in the Senate, ensuring every state and the FCT have dedicated female representation.

    Nigeria’s female representation in parliament currently stands below 5 percent, among the lowest in Africa. The new measure aims to address this disparity and align the country with global standards of gender inclusion in governance.

    ​  

    *Independent candidacy, extra legislative seats for women also endorsed Sunday Aborisade in Abuja In a historic decision that could redefine Nigeria’s political architecture and deepen democratic inclusivity, the Joint Committee

    Tinubu Felicitates Japan’s First Female Prime Minister, Sanae Takaichi, On Making History 

    Tinubu Felicitates Japan’s First Female Prime Minister, Sanae Takaichi, On Making History 

    Deji Elumoye in Abuja 

    President Bola Tinubu has sent a congratulatory letter to the first female Prime Minister of Japan, Sanae Takaichi, describing her emergence after winning the votes in the parliament as an affirmation of her contributions to the influence of her political party in governance in Japan.

    The President said he looks forward to working with Prime Minister Takaichi.

    In the seven-paragraph letter personally signed by him, President Tinubu stated, inter alia: “Your Excellency,

    on behalf of the people and Government of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, I extend to you my warmest congratulations on your election as the first female Prime Minister of Japan.

    “Your victory as the leader of the Liberal Democratic Party and ultimately as the Prime Minister of Japan constitutes a remarkable expression of the confidence reposed in you by the good people of Japan.

    “Your election as the first female Prime Minister of Japan is also a testament to the decades of your tremendous contributions to the growth of your political party and governance in Japan.

    “As you assume this mandate, you can please rest assured of Nigeria’s continued goodwill and support for Japan. Nigeria and Japan have maintained a deep, productive, and strategic relationship over the years, covering several areas of bilateral cooperation.

    “I am confident that we would work together to build on the foundation that has been laid, as well as strengthen and deepen the relationship between our two countries. I therefore look forward to meeting with you at your earliest convenience to explore these opportunities.

    “I am reassured that Nigeria-Japan relations would continue to blossom under your capable and visionary leadership.

    “Please accept the assurances of my highest esteem and best wishes for your good health and personal well-being.”

    ​  

    Deji Elumoye in Abuja  President Bola Tinubu has sent a congratulatory letter to the first female Prime Minister of Japan, Sanae Takaichi, describing her emergence after winning the votes in the

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Business & Economy

    NNPC lauds Ekperikpe, Mshelbila’s election into top positions in global gas forum

    NNPC lauds Ekperikpe, Mshelbila’s election into top positions in global gas forum

    Roxettes Group mulls relocating plants from Southeast to Lagos over insecurity  

    Lagos reintroduces another 61-day amnesty window on existing buildings without planning permit

    LivingTrust Mortgage Bank records N255.6 million pre-tax profit in Q3 2025, up 7.04% 

    Lagos insists computer village relocation will soon be a reality with flexible payment plan

    Abbey Mortgage posts N670 million pre-tax profit in Q3 2025, beats forecast

    Naira breaks below N2,000/£ against the British Pound Sterling

    ATM withdrawals climb to N15.97 trillion in Q1 2025 despite new fees 

    S&P Global Commodity Insights targets Nigeria’s mineral development push, opens country office

    S&P Global Commodity Insights targets Nigeria’s mineral development push, opens country office

    Canal+ takeover: MultiChoice to delist from Johannesburg Stock Exchange December 10  

    Red Star Express grows Q2 2025 profit by 98.8% as revenue hits N5.8 billion 

    Where to buy gold in Lagos: 5 markets every buyer should know 

    Access Holdings posts N320.57 billion pre-tax profit in first half of 2025 

    Top 10 high-paying artisan jobs in Germany for skilled migrants in 2025 

    Meet Maj. Gen. Waidi Shaibu, Nigeria’s new Chief of Army Staff 

    Fintech holds key to Africa’s $17 trillion real estate market – Virety CEO 

    Bank of Agriculture secures $200 million Livelihood Support Fund for displaced Nigerians  

    Lagos Free Zone remains the best investment destination for Nordic businesses in Nigeria – CEO, LFZ, Adesuwa Ladoja 

    Customs intercepts drugs concealed in imported vehicles worth N5.3 billion at Tin Can Port 

    DMO re-opens N260 billion AUG-2030, JUN-2032 bonds on Monday 

    Finally, Nigeria Exits FATF, Global Financial Crime Watchlist

    Abimbola Olashore: As Kids, We Used to Sit on NTA’sFloor for Tales By Moonlight

    Redesigning Skills for Nigeria, Others’ Creative Future

    Nivea Rolls-out 100million Fund to Advance Child Wellness

    Stallion Group Unveils 4 New MG Models in Nigeria

    Spiro Electric Bikes Cut Costs, Promote Cleaner Environment

    Report Says Human Skills Crucial to Stay Relevant in AI Era

    Naira strengthens to N1,455/$ as foreign reserves hit $42.8 billion 

    Aradel Holdings acquires 40% ND Western, deepens upstream footprint 

    FMDQ Exchange lists N30.05 billion fresh Commercial Papers in one week 

    Tigran Gambaryan: Court sets November 27 for judgement in detention case against Nigeria

    Tinubu hails FATF for removing Nigeria from grey list, calls it reform milestone 

    NGF, federal stakeholders, Woodhall Capital explore funding frameworks for state-led infrastructure – Organisers

    NGF, federal stakeholders, Woodhall Capital explore funding frameworks for state-led infrastructure – Organisers

    Kaduna: SON destroys N25 million worth of expired sugar, substandard goods

    IMTO inflows down $193.14 million in Q1 2025, miss remittance target

    FATF removes Nigeria from grey list, boosting investor confidence